Connect Before You Correct: Better Performance Conversations


Relational Fitness

Leading Others

Connect before you correct

“Lucie, I’m struggling to motivate my direct reports, and I feel so frustrated. I’ve had many conversations with them about their performance. They tell me they know, but their actions don’t change. Is it them or me?”

Maybe you’ve been there too. You finally have the talk. They nod and say, “I know, I’ll do it differently next time.” And then nothing changes.

Here’s what is often going on: “I know, I’ll fix it” can be a survival strategy. It’s the fastest way out of an uncomfortable conversation. It helps end the conversation. It doesn’t help anyone grow, them or you as a leader.

So it may not be them, or you. It may be how the conversation is set up.

One Idea: Connect before you correct

This month we’re focusing on difficult conversations. Last week was about the ones we avoid. This week is about the ones we do have, that still don’t get results. (This applies to our personal lives too, not just work!)

Most leaders lean one of two ways:

  • They jump straight to correcting. People get defensive, or say “I know” just to get out of the room.
  • They protect the connection so much that the message gets too soft to land. People leave feeling fine, but unclear on what needs to change. Or they promise to “try,” knowing nothing really happens if they don’t.

Effective performance conversations need both, in the right order: connect first, then align.

1. Connect

  • Connect with yourself first. Are you calm enough to have this conversation? Is this the right time and place? Separate the facts you’ve observed from your assumptions about why they happened.
  • Ask before telling. “How do you feel the presentation went?” Ask with curiosity, not judgment.
  • Listen, and validate what you genuinely can. Don’t interrupt. Find even 5% you can honestly acknowledge: “I can see you’re proud you finished on time. I know that’s been hard before.”

2. Align (instead of “correct”)

If you catch yourself thinking “I need to correct this,” notice the frustration that often comes with it. Thinking of this step as getting aligned helps you stay neutral.

  • Name the purpose early. “Thanks for sharing how it went for you. I really want you to succeed at this, so let’s talk about how to make it even better.”
  • Be specific about the gap. What you expected, what you observed, and its impact.
  • Ask what’s getting in the way, and what support would help.
  • Agree on next steps and a follow-up date.

This Week’s Practice: Pick your one step

Before your next performance conversation, choose the one step where you’ll grow the most:

  • If you’re a natural connector, practice being specific about the gap and agreeing on a follow-up date.
  • If you tend to jump straight to fixing, practice asking at least two open questions before sharing your view. Start them with “What”: “What went well?” “What got in the way?”

And if someone has told you “I know, I’ll fix it” before and nothing changed? Take a deep breath. This time, start with their view, validate what you genuinely can, and then brainstorm together what they could do differently.

A quick check-in on last week: I committed to drafting a message to one of my strategic partners. I drafted it, and I sent it! And I already got a reply :) Honestly, this newsletter kept me accountable. I almost “conveniently” forgot, until I sat down to write this email. Have you taken your small step? If yes, celebrate. If not, today is the next best time.

Which step are you practicing this week? Hit reply and tell me. I read every one.

Next week, we’ll look at how to stay clear-headed and calm in high-stress conversations.

With care and appreciation for your inner work,

Lucie
Founder and fellow practitioner, MindFittery
​Mental & Emotional Fitness Gym for Leaders

P.S. Want to practice validating and asking questions with other leaders, in a safe space? Sign up for one of our upcoming Inner Fitness Circles for Leaders here.

​Unsubscribe

The Weekly Practice by MindFittery

Any leadership starts with self-leadership. And that's where this newsletter starts too. Week by week, I'll share a small, practical step to help you strengthen your emotional intelligence so you can lead through chaos with more focus, calm, and clarity.

Read more from The Weekly Practice by MindFittery
A calendar invite for a feedback chat, rescheduled six times, finally landing on the performance review date.

Inner Game Leading Yourself What conversation are you avoiding? “Lucie, I just had a performance review with my leader and I’m so angry! They put things in writing that happened six months ago, and this is the first time I’m hearing about them. I thought I was doing well. Seeing this is so shocking and upsetting. I’ve lost trust in this relationship.” I wish this didn’t happen so often. Yet every year, several clients share a similar story. Their leader never gives them constructive feedback....

A crystal ball holding a storm cloud, with a small sun peeking out from behind it.

Strategic Reset Leading Forward What if... something bad happens? “I didn’t do a great job on the presentation, and for two days I couldn’t stop thinking: what if this made things worse for me with my leadership?” One Idea: The Misfortune Teller Sound familiar? One of the biggest energy drains I see in leaders is the constant “what if.” The presentation. The difficult conversation you’ve been avoiding. The deal, the reorg. The moment a team member pitches a new idea and, before you’ve said a...

Pressure Practice Navigating Challenges Challenge: Overwhelm “Lucie, my company went through a restructuring. Now I’m doing the job of two people, there’s a hiring freeze, and I’ve been told to figure out how to get more done using AI. I’m completely overwhelmed and stressed out.” I hear some version of this from many of my clients these days. Even if it isn’t your situation right now, you know this feeling: sudden changes, a growing workload, and the sense that you’re running just to stay in...