How to tame the Misfortune Teller


Strategic Reset

Leading Forward

What if... something bad happens?

“I didn’t do a great job on the presentation, and for two days I couldn’t stop thinking: what if this made things worse for me with my leadership?”

One Idea: The Misfortune Teller

Sound familiar? One of the biggest energy drains I see in leaders is the constant “what if.” The presentation. The difficult conversation you’ve been avoiding. The deal, the reorg. The moment a team member pitches a new idea and, before you’ve said a word, your mind is already listing everything that could go wrong.

I know this voice well. Mine worries about what other people might think: during and after networking, after a challenging conversation, before giving constructive feedback. With practice, it’s gotten quieter and I catch it faster. But it still creeps in, bringing anxiety and the urge to procrastinate on exactly the things it worries about.

I call this voice the Misfortune Teller. It pictures the worst case and waits for the other shoe to drop. You might feel it as tension headaches, restlessness, trouble resting or thinking clearly, or a hard time sitting with uncertainty.

For me, it usually pushes one of two ways. Either I rush into action just to get certainty (“I need to say this right now, or I can’t relax”), or I avoid an action because it carries risk (“What if they think I’m bothering them? Maybe it’s better not to reach out.”). You may recognize one of these, or both.

Its intention is good: it’s trying to keep you safe. It tells you, “If you stop watching for every risk, you’ll miss the one that matters.” But it goes about it in an exhausting way.

The cost adds up. Mental and emotional energy. Performance, as you double-check things that don’t need it and fall behind on what does. Or avoiding tasks that feel risky, even important ones. And with your team: when you mostly see risks in their ideas, they stop bringing them, and your anxiety spreads to them.

As the year winds down, with performance reviews and goal setting for next year ahead, the Misfortune Teller can get louder. So this week, I’m giving you one practice that helps with both the rushing and the avoiding.

This Week’s Practice: The 10% True Rule

You can’t argue the Misfortune Teller away, and you don’t have to obey it either. Its forecasts are rarely 100% false. They usually hold a kernel of truth, blown out of proportion. So instead of fighting it, sort it:

  1. Write down the worst case it’s predicting.
  2. Find the 10% that’s a real, valid risk.
  3. Of that 10%, what’s within your control? Make one concrete plan for just that.
  4. Consciously set the other 90% down. It’s exaggeration, not information.

Here’s how we used it in that coaching session. The 10% that was real: the presentation didn’t go as well as my client wanted. The part within their control: talking with their manager, asking for feedback, and agreeing on what to do differently next time. The other 90%, “my leadership now thinks I’m not capable,” was a story, not a fact. Seeing that difference moved us from replaying the past to planning a next step.

Use it with your team, too. When someone brings you a new idea and the risks start flooding in, try the rule out loud: “What’s the 10% here that’s a real risk? What can we control? Let’s plan for that and move forward.” You take the risk seriously without shutting the idea down.

If the Misfortune Teller is too loud to sort

Sorting needs your thinking brain online. If you’re too wound up to think straight, calm the system first, then sort:

  • Breathe out longer than you breathe in. A few slow breaths with a long exhale signal to your body that you’re safe.
  • Listen far, then near. Notice the farthest sound you can hear, then the closest one. It pulls your attention out of the future and into the present.
  • Name it. “This is the Misfortune Teller talking.” Research shows that putting a label on a feeling calms the brain’s threat center and brings the thinking brain back online. (Much easier to say than Rumpelstiltskin!) ;)
  • Give it a schedule. Set aside 15 minutes at 4 pm for worries. When the Misfortune Teller speaks up at 1 pm, tell it: “We’ll review this at 4.”

What’s your Misfortune Teller’s favorite “what if”? Try the 10% rule on it and hit reply. I’d love to hear what you find.

If you’ve read this far, acknowledge yourself for the time and effort you’re putting into your growth and your mental and emotional fitness.

With care and appreciation for your inner work,

Lucie

Founder and fellow practitioner at MindFittery

MindFittery: Mental and Emotional Fitness Gym for Leaders

P.S. The Misfortune Teller is one of several “Saboteurs” that hijack our energy and leadership. Want to find out which ones are loudest for you? Reply “assessment” and I’ll send you the free Saboteur Assessment, then help you debrief your results.

​Unsubscribe

The Weekly Practice by MindFittery

Any leadership starts with self-leadership. And that's where this newsletter starts too. Week by week, I'll share a small, practical step to help you strengthen your emotional intelligence so you can lead through chaos with more focus, calm, and clarity.

Read more from The Weekly Practice by MindFittery
A calendar invite for a feedback chat, rescheduled six times, finally landing on the performance review date.

Inner Game Leading Yourself What conversation are you avoiding? “Lucie, I just had a performance review with my leader and I’m so angry! They put things in writing that happened six months ago, and this is the first time I’m hearing about them. I thought I was doing well. Seeing this is so shocking and upsetting. I’ve lost trust in this relationship.” I wish this didn’t happen so often. Yet every year, several clients share a similar story. Their leader never gives them constructive feedback....

Pressure Practice Navigating Challenges Challenge: Overwhelm “Lucie, my company went through a restructuring. Now I’m doing the job of two people, there’s a hiring freeze, and I’ve been told to figure out how to get more done using AI. I’m completely overwhelmed and stressed out.” I hear some version of this from many of my clients these days. Even if it isn’t your situation right now, you know this feeling: sudden changes, a growing workload, and the sense that you’re running just to stay in...

A frustrated leader and a worried team member, with a jagged line between them turning into a calm wave.

Leading Others “Why does this keep happening? I’ve explained it three times, and it’s still not done right. Now I have to talk to them again...” Meanwhile, down the hall: “I’m dreading this meeting. They always seem rushed and upset with me.” Same meeting. Same energy drain. Different reasons. First, a quick check-in: Last week I committed to three morning walks as part of my 10% energy improvement. Result: only one happened in the morning, but I walked mid-morning or in the afternoon...